Table 2.

Comparison of trauma-informed care, ACEs, and ERH concepts

CHARACTERISTICCONCEPT
TRAUMA-INFORMED CARE15CONSIDERATION OF ACEs16ERH17
DefinitionAcknowledges that health care organizations and teams need to have a complete picture of a patient’s life to provide effective health care services with a healing orientationPotentially traumatic events occurring in childhoodEmotional connections between children and trusted adults; often defined as an SSNR
Impact
  • Patients with trauma have difficulty maintaining open relationships with health care providers

  • Improved long-term health outcomes for patients

  • Providers working with populations experiencing trauma experience burnout and higher turnover

Associated with health or developmental challenges and negative long-term physical and mental effects
  • SSNRs serve as the foundation for building resilience

  • Promotes health and development

  • Leads to positive experiences

  • Can buffer negative effects of trauma and adversity

ConsiderationsCore principles:
  • Safety

  • Trustworthiness and transparency

  • Peer support

  • Collaboration

  • Empowerment

  • Humility and responsiveness

  • Abuse (eg, physical, emotional, sexual)

  • Neglect (eg, physical, emotional)

  • Household challenges (eg, mental illness, parental history of violence, substance abuse, incarceration, divorce)

Use each clinical encounter to promote parenting behaviour that will help children develop
Methods
  • Create safe, caring, inclusive environments (physical, social, and emotional) for all patients

  • Change organizational culture and atmosphere

  • Address trauma with trained individuals at the clinical level

  • Seek to address modifiable risk factors to transmit resilience

  • Teach parenting skills and family relationship approaches to strengthen parent-child relationships

  • Understand and address factors that put people at risk for or protect them from violence

  • Reduce stigma related to seeking help

  • Advocate for stronger economic support of families

  • Promote early childhood education

  • Connect youth to caring adults and activities

  • Discuss specific aspects of parenting behaviour that support the concept (eg, noticing and responding to baby’s cues to promote secure attachment)

  • Model behaviour during the visit (eg, warm back-and-forth interactions)

  • Praise what you observe (eg, baby calms down when parent holds them)

  • Recommend community support services

Rationale
  • Improves patient engagement

  • Improves treatment adherence

  • Improves health outcomes

  • Improves provider wellness

  • Reduces care visits and decreases costs to health care and social services

  • Reduces the incidence of chronic health conditions

  • Addresses health inequity

  • Decreases health care costs associated with ACE-related consequences

  • Preemptive parental assessment and guidance build confidence and skills in parents

  • Positive parenting behaviour allows children to develop secure attachment, autonomy, self-regulation, perspective taking, and problem solving

  • ERH is predictive of later well-being

  • ACE—adverse childhood experience; ERH—early relational health; SSNR—safe, stable, and nurturing relationship.

  • Data from the Center for Health Care Strategies,15 the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,16 and Agnihotri and Williams.