Table 1.

When SDM should be considered

CARE OPTIONS*CATEGORIESEXAMPLES
There are at least 2 medically valid options with a balance between benefits and harms
  • If the recommendation is in favour of action, SDM should precede ordering the test or treatment

  • Mammography in women 50–74 y10

  • Screening for abdominal aortic aneurysm in men 65–80 y11

  • Statins for primary prevention of CVD in people at moderate risk

Many weak or conditional recommendations12
  • If the recommendation is against action, SDM is useful when the patient wants to know more about the option

  • PSA screening in men 55–70 y13

  • Mammography in women in their 40s10

In specific circumstances even if the balance between benefit and harms is usually not in equipoise
  • The balance between benefits and risks is different for a particular patient

  • A potentially lifesaving surgery in a patient with multiple comorbidities in whom potential harms are important

Some strong recommendations in favour of action12
  • A patient who expresses the desire to discuss a specific recommendation

  • Colon cancer screening in adults 60–74 y14

  • CVD—cardiovascular disease, PSA—prostate-specific antigen, SDM—shared decision making.

  • * When there is a decision to be made and the patient can collaborate.