Evidence for intervals of repeat screening
DISEASE OR CONDITION | SOURCE OF RECOMMENDATION | SOURCE OF EVIDENCE | AGE TO START OR STOP SCREENING | INTERVAL RECOMMENDATION |
---|---|---|---|---|
Cancer | ||||
Cervical | ||||
• Papanicolaou tests | CTFPHC guideline8 | International Agency for Research on Cancer9 | 25-70 y | 3 y |
• HPV tests | American Cancer Society guideline10 | American Cancer Society10 | 25-70 y | 5 y |
Breast | CTFPHC guideline1 | Meta-analysis11 | 50-75 y | 2-3 y |
Colorectal | CTFPHC guideline12 | Trials13,14 | 50-74 y | 2 y |
Lung | European expert group15 | Trials16,17 | 60-80 y | Annually at first, then every 2 or more y |
Cardiovascular | ||||
Hypertension and dyslipidemia | European expert group18* | Modeling using Whitehall study18 | > 40 y | Low risk: 7 y Intermediate risk: 4 y Intermediate to high risk: 1 y |
Diabetes | CTFPHC guideline1† | Meta-analysis19 | 40 y | Low risk: no screen Medium risk: every 3-5 y High risk: annual |
Other | ||||
Osteoporotic fracture | Cohort study20 | Gourlay et al20 | Women: ≥ 65 y Men: insufficient evidence | T-score -1.5 to -2: 15 y T-score <-2 to -2.5: 5 y |
Cohort study21 | Crandall et al21 | Screen once (no repeat) | ||
Abdominal aortic aneurysm | CTFPHC guideline2 | Meta-analysis2 | Men: 65 y | Once (no repeat) |
ASCVD—atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease, CTFPHC—Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care, FINDRISC—Finnish Diabetes Risk Score, HPV—human papillomavirus.
↵*Cardiovascular risk was defined by the ASCVD calculator as the 10-year risk of cardiovascular events (myocardial infarction, death from coronary artery disease, fatal or nonfatal stroke). Low risk was defined as less than 2.5%. Intermediate risk was from 2.5% to less than 5%. Intermediate to high risk was from 5% to 10%. High risk was greater than 10%, which was the threshold for active management.
↵†Diabetes risk was determined by FINDRISC22: ≤ 14 points: low risk, no screen; 15 to 20 points: medium risk, screen every 3 to 5 y; ≥ 21 points: high risk, screen annually.