ArticlesReduction in overdose mortality after the opening of North America's first medically supervised safer injecting facility: a retrospective population-based study
Introduction
Injecting drug users (IDUs) have a much higher risk of morbidity and mortality than does the general population.1 Accidental drug overdose is a leading cause of death in IDUs, and contributes substantially to mortality in communities in which injection drug use is prevalent.2 In some North American cities, overdose has overtaken homicide as the leading cause of premature mortality.3 In 2007, the rate of unintentional drug overdose death in the USA (nine deaths per 100 000 person-years) was about five times higher than in 1990.4 Overdose mortality rates are highest in ethnic minorities: in the USA, overdose deaths are more common in African American and Hispanic individuals,5 whereas in Canada, First Nations individuals are more likely than individuals from the general population to die from an overdose.6
The primary mechanism of death attributable to opioid overdose is respiratory depression and resultant hypoxia.7 Seizures, cardiac arrhythmias, stroke, and hyperthermia have been implicated in deaths related to cocaine overdose.8, 9 Risk factors for fatal overdose include both individual and environmental factors. Polydrug use (notably the concomitant consumption of opioids and alcohol),10 public drug use,11 release from prison,12 and warmer weather13 have all been associated with an increased risk of fatal overdose. Although the risk factors for fatal overdose have been well described, there are few evidence-based strategies to reduce the risk of overdose mortality that have proved effective in population-based studies.
In Vancouver, BC, Canada, high rates of overdose mortality in the 1990s14 led to the establishment of North America's first medically supervised safer injecting facility (SIF) in the city's Downtown Eastside, a community known for its large open drug market and well described HIV epidemic.15 The local drug use context is characterised by high rates of polysubstance use, including heroin, cocaine, and metamfetamine injection in addition to crack cocaine smoking.16 The neighbourhood is also characterised by a concentration of low-cost housing (eg, single room occupancy hotels), large numbers of homeless people, and high levels of drug-related disorder, including public drug injecting.17 The SIF is located centrally in this neighbourhood, with the aims of reducing public drug injection, decreasing overdose and risk of infectious disease (eg, HIV) transmission, and improving access to health-care services.18 The local police department supported the opening of the SIF, and throughout the study period officers have actively referred individuals found injecting in public to the facility.19 Similar to the about 65 SIFs that exist around the world,20 IDUs consume pre-obtained illicit drugs under the supervision of health-care professionals, who provide sterile syringes and referrals to primary health services, as well as emergency care in the event of overdose (eg, oxygen and naloxone administration).21 Staff are instructed to call an ambulance in the event of a serious overdose; to date, no deaths within the facility have been recorded.22 Although heroin has been reported as the most frequently injected drug in the facility (about 40% of all injections), powder cocaine (about 30%) and metamfetamines (5%) are common.23 In earlier analyses,24 the SIF has been shown to attract IDUs who are at an increased risk of blood-borne disease acquisition and overdose.25 Use of the SIF has also been associated with reductions in HIV risk behaviour, including syringe sharing,26 an increased uptake of addiction services,27 and improved access to health and social services.28
Although SIFs have been associated with public health and community benefits in several international settings,20 they remain controversial.29 For example, in Canada, although the facility has garnered broad public and local support,30 it continues to be opposed by the federal government.31 Some have argued that objective outcomes, as opposed to self-reported behavioural data, are required to definitively establish the true effectiveness of SIFs, and it is worth noting that there is an absence of rigorous assessments of their effect on overdose mortality.32 To address these concerns, we undertook a population-based examination of drug-related overdose mortality rates before and after the establishment of North America's first SIF.
Section snippets
Procedures
Data for these analyses were derived from a review of files obtained from a central registry maintained by British Columbia Coroners Service (BCCS). Because the BCCS is responsible for investigating and documenting all unnatural, unexpected, unexplained, or unattended deaths,33 the registry is highly accurate, and therefore serves as the best available census of deaths caused by an illicit drug overdose in the province. Coroners of the agency are required to determine the identity of the
Results
Between Jan 1, 2001, and Dec 31, 2005, 290 accidental illicit drug overdoses occurred within the city boundaries of Vancouver—an average of 1·1 per week. Men accounted for 229 (79·0%) deaths, and the median age at death was 40 years (IQR 32–48). We did not detect evidence of seasonality in the rates of overdose; an ANOVA analysis showed that the mean number of overdoses did not vary significantly when the study period was divided into 3-month periods (F=0·365, p=0·780). The crude mortality rate
Discussion
In this population-based analysis, we showed that overdose mortality was reduced after the opening of a SIF. Reductions in overdose rates were most evident within the close vicinity of the facility—a 35% reduction in mortality was noted within 500 m of the facility after its opening. By contrast, overdose deaths in other areas of the city during the same period declined by only 9%. Consistent with earlier evidence showing that SIFs are not associated with increased drug injecting (panel),38, 39
References (57)
- et al.
Mortality among injecting drug users in Melbourne: a 16-year follow-up of the Victorian Injecting Cohort Study (VICS)
Drug Alcohol Depend
(2008) - et al.
Circumstances and witness characteristics associated with overdose fatality
Ann Emerg Med
(2009) - et al.
Public injection settings in Vancouver: physical environment, social context and risk
Int J Drug Policy
(2007) - et al.
Rationale for evaluating North America's first medically supervised safer-injecting facility
Lancet Infect Dis
(2004) - et al.
Drug-related overdoses within a medically supervised safer injection facility
Int J Drug Policy
(2006) - et al.
Attendance, drug use patterns, and referrals made from North America's first supervised injection facility
Drug Alcohol Depend
(2006) - et al.
Do supervised injecting facilities attract higher-risk injection drug users?
Am J Prev Med
(2005) - et al.
Safer injection facility use and syringe sharing in injection drug users
Lancet
(2005) - et al.
Accessing care for injection-related infections through a medically supervised injecting facility: a qualitative study
Drug Alcohol Depend
(2008) - et al.
Supervised injecting facilities: time for scale-up?
Lancet
(2008)
The Canadian government's treatment of scientific process and evidence: inside the evaluation of North America's first supervised injecting facility
Int J Drug Policy
Being realistic about benefits of supervised injecting facilities
Lancet
Injection drug users' perceptions regarding use of a medically supervised safer injecting facility
Addict Behav
Incidence and determinants of initiation into cocaine injection and correlates of frequent cocaine injectors
Drug Alcohol Depend
Seeking refuge from violence in street-based drug scenes: women's experiences in North America's first supervised injection facility
Soc Sci Med
Factors associated with geographic migration among a cohort of injection drug users
Health Place
The quantification of mortality resulting from the regular use of illicit opiates
Addiction
Increase in fatal poisonings involving opioid analgesics in the United States, 1999–2006. NCHS data brief, no 22
Unintentional drug poisoning in the United States. National Center for Injury Prevention and Control, CDC
Racial/ethnic disparities in overdose mortality trends in New York City, 1990–1998
J Urban Health
Elevated overdose mortality rates among First Nations individuals in a Canadian setting: a population-based analysis
Addiction
Mechanisms of fatal opioid overdose
Addiction
Mechanism of cocaine-induced hyperthermia in humans
Ann Intern Med
Non-fatal cocaine overdose among injecting and non-injecting cocaine users in Sydney, Australia
Addiction
Heroin overdose: research and evidence-based intervention
J Urban Health
Release from prison—a high risk of death for former inmates
N Engl J Med
Ambient temperature and risk of death from accidental drug overdose in New York City, 1990–2006
Addiction
Drug-related overdose deaths in British Columbia and Ontario, 1992–2004
Can J Public Health
Cited by (349)
Overcoming stigma: Community support for overdose prevention sites
2024, International Journal of Drug PolicyA qualitative study on perceptions and experiences of overdose among people who smoke drugs in Vancouver, British Columbia
2024, Drug and Alcohol DependenceEffect of modified income assistance payment schedules on substance use service access: Evidence from an experimental study
2024, International Journal of Drug Policy